| 9/5/2009 | Shenandoah 21 @ Catholic 3 | |
| 9/12/2009 | Catholic 21 @ Franklin & Marshall 42 | |
| 9/19/2009 | Catholic 17 @ McDaniel 21 | |
| 9/26/2009 | Randolph-Macon 31 @ Catholic 21 | † |
| 10/10/2009 | Catholic 14 @ Washington and Lee 28 | † |
| 10/17/2009 | Catholic 38 @ Gallaudet 13 | |
| 10/24/2009 | Hampden-Sydney 21 @ Catholic 7 | † |
| 10/31/2009 | Emory & Henry 13 @ Catholic 10 | † |
| 11/7/2009 | Guilford 42 @ Catholic 21 | † |
| 11/14/2009 | Catholic 13 @ Bridgewater VA 30 | † |