Earlham

5-5 (3-4 North Coast Athletic)

9/5/2009 Rose-Hulman 61 @ Earlham 24
9/12/2009 Manchester 21 @ Earlham 31
9/19/2009 Earlham 37 @ Anderson 34
10/3/2009 Wooster 49 @ Earlham 3 †
10/10/2009 Wittenberg 42 @ Earlham 3 †
10/17/2009 Earlham 10 @ Hiram 7 †
10/24/2009 Oberlin 19 @ Earlham 13 †
10/31/2009 Kenyon 9 @ Earlham 21 †
11/7/2009 Earlham 7 @ Ohio Wesleyan 20 †
11/14/2009 Earlham 21 @ Denison 17 †