Ohio Wesleyan

3-7 (3-4 North Coast Athletic)

9/5/2009 Ohio Wesleyan 7 @ Carnegie Mellon 19
9/19/2009 Wooster 37 @ Ohio Wesleyan 20 †
9/26/2009 Ohio Wesleyan 0 @ Wittenberg 20 †
10/3/2009 Oberlin 14 @ Ohio Wesleyan 17 †
10/10/2009 Ohio Wesleyan 28 @ Kenyon 33 †
10/17/2009 Ohio Wesleyan 7 @ Case Western Reserve 55
10/24/2009 Washington U 26 @ Ohio Wesleyan 14
10/31/2009 Ohio Wesleyan 38 @ Hiram 6 †
11/7/2009 Earlham 7 @ Ohio Wesleyan 20 †
11/14/2009 Allegheny 30 @ Ohio Wesleyan 13 †