Bluffton

0-10 (0-7 Heartland Collegiate Athletic)

9/5/2009 Alma 28 @ Bluffton 16
9/19/2009 Adrian 41 @ Bluffton 7
9/26/2009 Bluffton 27 @ Kalamazoo 47
10/3/2009 Bluffton 18 @ Mt St Joseph 38 †
10/10/2009 Franklin 28 @ Bluffton 12 †
10/17/2009 Bluffton 7 @ Manchester 23 †
10/24/2009 Rose-Hulman 50 @ Bluffton 14 †
10/31/2009 Anderson 28 @ Bluffton 3 †
11/7/2009 Bluffton 19 @ Hanover 52 †
11/14/2009 Bluffton 0 @ Defiance 35 †