| 9/3/2016 | Concordia WI | 31 | at | Finlandia | 14 | NAC | ||
| Maranatha Baptist | 20 | at | Martin Luther | 7 | @ UMWAC | |||
| Apprentice | 20 | at | Methodist | 24 | @ USASC | |||
| Alfred State | 13 | at | William Paterson | 43 | @ NJAC | |||
| 9/10/2016 | Brockport State | 49 | at | Alfred State | 0 | E8 | ||
| Apprentice | 42 | at | Greensboro | 22 | @ USASC | |||
| Finlandia | 5 | at | Lawrence | 14 | @ MidW | |||
| Rockford | 34 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 6 | NAC | |||
| 9/17/2016 | Rochester | 55 | at | Alfred State | 27 | LL | ||
| Bridgewater VA | 23 | at | Apprentice | 26 | ODC | |||
| Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 68 | at | Finlandia | 7 | WIAC | |||
| Maranatha Baptist | 14 | at | Trinity Bible | 33 | @ None (Unk?) | |||
| 9/24/2016 | Apprentice | 7 | at | Brevard | 38 | @ SAC (D2) | ||
| Alfred State | 0 | at | Husson | 35 | @ ECFC | |||
| Concordia IL | 42 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 10 | NAC | |||
| Finlandia | 0 | at | Wartburg | 56 | @ IIAC | |||
| 10/1/2016 | Apprentice | 24 | at | Alfred State | 8 | |||
| 10/8/2016 | Finlandia | 20 | at | Trinity Bible | 36 | @ None (Unk?) | ||
| 10/15/2016 | Buffalo State | 27 | at | Alfred State | 0 | E8 | ||
| Finlandia | 0 | at | Presentation | 74 | @ NSAA (NAIA) | |||
| 10/22/2016 | Maranatha Baptist | 22 | at | Finlandia | 27 | |||
| 10/29/2016 | Kentucky Wesleyan | 52 | at | Alfred State | 7 | D2Ind (D2) | ||
| Trinity Bible | 18 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 34 | None (Unk?) | |||
| 11/5/2016 | Webber International | 42 | at | Apprentice | 14 | Sun (NAIA) | ||
| Trinity Bible | 17 | at | Finlandia | 13 | None (Unk?) | |||
| Alfred State | 21 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 7 | ||||
| 11/12/2016 | Ave Maria | 20 | at | Apprentice | 24 | Sun (NAIA) | ||
| Minnesota-Morris | 38 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 13 | UMWAC | |||
| Alfred State | 20 | at | Morrisville | 62 | @ E8 |