| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Akron | 1-11 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (3-6) | 9/15/2012 | W 66-6 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Alabama State | 7-3 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 9/2/2012 | L 28-38 vs |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Appalachian State | 8-4 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (7-4) | 9/29/2012 | W 55-14 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Arizona | 8-5 |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (5-4) | 9/15/2012 | W 56-0 |
|
| 5-3 | — | 0 | (6 Common Ops) | 1 | Bethune-Cookman | 8-3 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (6-5) | 11/24/2012 | L 14-24 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (3-6) | 11/3/2012 | W 24-13 at |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (3-5) | 10/20/2012 | W 48-3 |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (4-5) | 11/17/2012 | W 21-16 vs |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (5-4) | 9/8/2012 | W 27-14 at |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (5-3) | 10/27/2012 | W 42-17 |
| 4-2 | 26-28 | 5-1 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Buffalo | 4-8 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (3-6) | 9/8/2012 | W 56-34 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Charleston Southern | 3-6 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (6-5) | 11/17/2012 | L 20-41 at |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Cincinnati | 10-3 |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (5-4) | 9/15/2012 | W 23-7 |
|
| 5-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 1 | Coastal Carolina | 7-5 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (8-2) | 11/24/2012 | W 24-14 at |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Delaware | 5-5 |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (5-4) | 9/8/2012 | W 38-14 |
|
| 5-3 | — | 0 | (6 Common Ops) | 1 | Delaware State | 5-5 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (3-6) | 10/25/2012 | W 28-23 at |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (4-4) | 11/17/2012 | L 34-41 at |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (3-5) | 10/6/2012 | W 20-17 at |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (3-6) | 9/22/2012 | L 22-24 |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (5-4) | 10/13/2012 | W 31-17 |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (4-4) | 11/3/2012 | L 20-23 1 at |
| 5-1 | 22-29 | 3-3 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Duke | 6-7 |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (5-3) | 9/15/2012 | W 54-17 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Eastern Kentucky | 8-3 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (7-4) | 9/15/2012 | W 35-17 at |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Elon | 2-8 |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (5-3) | 9/8/2012 | W 34-14 |
|
| 4-4 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | Florida A&M | 4-6 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 11/17/2012 | L 16-21 vs |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (4-4) | 10/6/2012 | L 10-17 at |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (5-4) | 9/22/2012 | W 24-22 at |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (4-5) | 10/20/2012 | L 20-27 1 |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (5-3) | 11/10/2012 | W 22-21 |
| 3-2 | 25-19 | 2-3 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Furman | 3-8 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (6-5) | 9/8/2012 | L 45-47 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Gardner-Webb | 2-8 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (6-5) | 11/3/2012 | L 33-56 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Georgia Southern | 10-4 |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (5-3) | 11/10/2012 | W 69-26 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Georgia State | 1-10 |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (4-5) | 8/30/2012 | L 6-33 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (7 Common Ops) | 0 | Hampton | 3-7 |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (3-6) | 9/15/2012 | L 20-44 at |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 9/29/2012 | L 26-38 |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (3-5) | 10/13/2012 | W 28-14 |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (4-4) | 10/18/2012 | L 20-37 at |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (4-4) | 11/3/2012 | L 10-20 at |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (4-5) | 11/10/2012 | L 27-35 at |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (3-6) | 11/17/2012 | W 27-17 at |
| 4-3 | 28-33 | 2-5 |
|
| 4-4 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | Howard | 5-4 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (2-7) | 10/20/2012 | L 20-21 |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (5-4) | 11/17/2012 | W 41-34 |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (3-5) | 9/15/2012 | W 37-36 at |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (4-5) | 10/6/2012 | W 17-10 |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (4-5) | 10/27/2012 | L 23-41 at |
| 3-2 | 18-26 | 3-2 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Liberty | 5-5 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (6-5) | 10/27/2012 | L 12-36 at |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (2-6) | 9/8/2012 | L 24-31 |
| 1-1 | 8-11 | 0-2 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Miami-Florida | 7-5 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (8-2) | 9/15/2012 | W 38-10 |
|
| 5-3 | — | 0 | (5 Common Ops) | 1 | Morgan State | 3-7 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 11/3/2012 | L 13-24 |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (5-3) | 10/20/2012 | W 21-20 at |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (4-5) | 10/25/2012 | L 23-28 |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (2-6) | 11/10/2012 | L 0-30 at |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (4-4) | 10/13/2012 | L 20-24 |
| 3-2 | 22-21 | 1-4 |
|
| 4-4 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | Norfolk State | 3-6 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (3-6) | 11/10/2012 | W 30-0 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 10/20/2012 | L 3-48 at |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (4-4) | 9/15/2012 | L 36-37 |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (4-5) | 10/6/2012 | L 17-20 |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (4-5) | 9/29/2012 | L 0-14 at |
| 2-3 | 22-23 | 1-4 |
|
| 4-4 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | North Carolina Central | 5-4 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (3-6) | 10/13/2012 | W 24-20 at |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 10/27/2012 | L 17-42 at |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (5-4) | 11/3/2012 | W 23-20 1 |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (3-6) | 11/10/2012 | L 21-22 at |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (5-4) | 10/6/2012 | W 40-10 vs |
| 2-3 | 23-23 | 3-2 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Ohio | 9-4 |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (3-5) | 9/22/2012 | W 44-10 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Oklahoma | 10-3 |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (4-5) | 9/8/2012 | W 69-13 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Old Dominion | 10-3 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (7-4) | 12/1/2012 | W 63-35 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Presbyterian | 1-9 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (6-5) | 11/10/2012 | L 7-65 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Rutgers | 9-4 |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (5-3) | 9/8/2012 | W 26-0 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Sacred Heart | 2-9 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (2-7) | 9/1/2012 | L 27-30 at |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (7 Common Ops) | 0 | Savannah State | 0-10 |
| L 18-21 | 9/27/2012 | Morgan State (2-7) | 10/6/2012 | L 6-45 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 11/10/2012 | L 7-49 |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (4-4) | 9/29/2012 | L 9-56 at |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (2-6) | 11/3/2012 | L 21-33 at |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (3-6) | 10/13/2012 | L 3-44 at |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (4-5) | 11/17/2012 | L 13-27 at |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (4-4) | 9/22/2012 | L 33-45 |
| 5-2 | 26-35 | 0-7 |
|
| 4-4 | — | 1 | (6 Common Ops) | 0 | South Carolina State | 5-5 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (7-3) | 9/8/2012 | L 14-27 |
| W 30-9 | 10/27/2012 | Norfolk State (3-5) | 9/29/2012 | W 14-0 |
| W 22-16 1 at | 11/17/2012 | North Carolina Central (4-4) | 10/6/2012 | L 10-40 vs |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (4-5) | 10/13/2012 | L 17-31 at |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (4-5) | 10/20/2012 | W 27-20 1 at |
| W 38-10 | 10/13/2012 | Howard (5-3) | 10/27/2012 | W 41-23 |
| 4-2 | 27-25 | 3-3 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Southern | 4-7 |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (4-5) | 9/29/2012 | W 21-14 vs |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Stony Brook | 9-3 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (7-4) | 10/13/2012 | W 27-21 at |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Tennessee State | 8-3 |
| L 12-28 at | 10/6/2012 | Bethune-Cookman (8-2) | 9/22/2012 | W 21-14 at |
| W 16-3 | 11/3/2012 | Florida A&M (4-5) | 9/1/2012 | W 17-14 |
| 1-1 | 12-7 | 2-0 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Texas A&M | 11-2 |
| W 17-7 | 11/10/2012 | South Carolina State (5-4) | 9/22/2012 | W 70-14 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Toledo | 9-4 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (7-4) | 9/22/2012 | W 38-28 |
|
| 5-4 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | VMI | 1-9 |
| L 13-29 at | 9/1/2012 | Coastal Carolina (6-5) | 10/20/2012 | L 7-34 |
| L 0-24 at | 10/20/2012 | Delaware State (4-5) | 9/1/2012 | L 10-17 at |
| 0-2 | 10-10 | 0-2 |
|