9/5/2009 | Albion D3 | 3 | @ | Butler | 42 | ||||
9/12/2009 | Butler | 49 | @ | Franklin D3 | 19 | ||||
9/19/2009 | Hanover D3 | 21 | @ | Butler | 42 | ||||
9/26/2009 | Butler | 28 | @ | Morehead St | 21 | Pio | |||
10/3/2009 | San Diego | 24 | @ | Butler | 25 | Pio | |||
10/17/2009 | Valparaiso | 14 | @ | Butler | 23 | Pio | |||
10/24/2009 | Butler | 23 | @ | Campbell | 16 | Pio | |||
10/31/2009 | Davidson | 7 | @ | Butler | 14 | Pio | |||
11/7/2009 | Butler | 31 | @ | Dayton | 28 | Pio | |||
11/14/2009 | Butler | 7 | @ | Jacksonville | 36 | Pio | |||
11/21/2009 | Drake | 17 | @ | Butler | 20 | Pio |