| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Appalachian St | 11-3 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (2-5) | 10/10/2009 | W 55-21 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Army | 5-7 |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 11/14/2009 | W 22-17 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Auburn | 8-5 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (9-2) | 9/19/2009 | W 41-30 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Brown | 6-4 |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (4-5) | 9/19/2009 | L 20-21 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Bucknell | 4-7 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 10/31/2009 | L 14-35 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Buffalo | 5-7 |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (4-3) | 10/10/2009 | W 40-3 |
|
| 6-3 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | Charleston So | 5-4 |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (3-4) | 10/17/2009 | L 20-27 at |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 10/31/2009 | W 31-21 at |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 11/7/2009 | W 46-32 at |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (5-4) | 11/14/2009 | W 30-27 1 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (5-4) | 11/21/2009 | W 30-23 |
| 4-1 | 15-28 | 4-1 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Chattanooga | 5-5 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 9/19/2009 | W 29-13 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Cincinnati | 12-1 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (9-2) | 11/13/2009 | W 24-21 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Clemson | 9-5 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (5-4) | 10/31/2009 | W 49-3 |
|
| 6-3 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | Coastal Car | 5-5 |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 10/10/2009 | W 20-6 |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (4-5) | 10/24/2009 | L 10-16 at |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (4-3) | 11/7/2009 | W 26-21 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 11/14/2009 | W 41-37 |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (4-4) | 11/21/2009 | L 23-30 at |
| 4-1 | 14-28 | 3-2 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Colgate | 9-2 |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (5-4) | 9/12/2009 | W 23-13 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 11/7/2009 | L 49-56 at |
| 1-1 | 12-6 | 1-1 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Colorado | 3-9 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 10/1/2009 | L 24-35 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Columbia | 4-6 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 10/10/2009 | L 21-24 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Connecticut | 8-5 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 10/24/2009 | L 24-28 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Delaware | 5-5 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (4-5) | 10/31/2009 | L 8-20 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Duke | 5-7 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (2-5) | 9/26/2009 | W 49-14 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | East Carolina | 9-5 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 9/12/2009 | L 20-35 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Elon | 9-3 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 9/12/2009 | W 41-7 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Florida | 13-1 |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (5-3) | 9/5/2009 | W 62-3 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Florida St | 6-7 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 1/1/2010 | L 21-33 vs |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Fordham | 5-6 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 10/24/2009 | L 21-26 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Furman | 6-5 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 9/5/2009 | W 45-21 |
|
| 6-3 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | Gardner Webb | 4-4 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (4-5) | 11/7/2009 | L 21-26 at |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (5-3) | 10/17/2009 | W 27-20 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 11/21/2009 | W 21-14 at |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 10/3/2009 | W 27-23 at |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (4-5) | 10/31/2009 | L 14-24 |
| 4-1 | 15-29 | 3-2 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Georgetown | 0-11 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 9/12/2009 | L 3-28 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Hampton | 5-6 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (2-5) | 9/5/2009 | W 31-24 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Harvard | 7-3 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 10/17/2009 | L 18-35 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Hofstra | 6-5 |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (5-4) | 9/5/2009 | W 17-10 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (5-4) | 10/3/2009 | W 24-17 |
| 0-2 | 10-8 | 2-0 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Holy Cross | 8-4 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (8-1) | 11/14/2009 | W 28-26 |
|
| 7-2 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 1 | James Madison | 5-5 |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 9/19/2009 | W 44-16 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Kent St | 5-7 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (5-4) | 9/3/2009 | W 18-0 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Lehigh | 4-7 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (8-1) | 11/21/2009 | W 27-21 1 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Louisville | 4-8 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 11/7/2009 | L 9-17 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Maine | 4-6 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (4-5) | 11/7/2009 | L 14-22 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Marshall | 7-6 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 10/17/2009 | L 7-24 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Maryland | 2-10 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (5-4) | 9/12/2009 | W 38-35 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Massachusetts | 5-6 |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (5-4) | 9/26/2009 | W 44-17 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (4-5) | 11/14/2009 | L 14-17 |
| 0-2 | 9-9 | 1-1 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Monmouth NJ | 5-6 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (4-5) | 9/12/2009 | L 17-24 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Morehead St | 2-8 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (2-5) | 9/19/2009 | W 13-10 2 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | NC A&T | 4-6 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (2-5) | 10/3/2009 | W 23-17 1 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (4-5) | 9/26/2009 | L 7-28 at |
| 2-0 | 6-10 | 1-1 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | North Carolina St | 5-7 |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (4-3) | 9/19/2009 | W 45-14 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | North Dakota | 5-4 |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (5-4) | 10/10/2009 | W 31-24 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (3 Common Ops) | 0 | Old Dominion | 7-2 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (2-5) | 11/7/2009 | W 42-28 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 10/10/2009 | W 34-16 |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 11/21/2009 | W 42-35 at |
| 3-0 | 4-21 | 3-0 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Penn | 8-2 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 9/26/2009 | L 17-20 1 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Pittsburgh | 10-3 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 11/27/2009 | L 16-19 at |
|
| 6-3 | — | 1 | (5 Common Ops) | 0 | Presbyterian | 0-10 |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (4-5) | 10/3/2009 | L 14-52 at |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (1-8) | 10/24/2009 | L 20-31 |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (4-4) | 11/7/2009 | L 32-46 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (4-5) | 11/14/2009 | L 37-41 at |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (3-4) | 11/21/2009 | L 14-21 |
| 4-1 | 16-26 | 0-5 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Richmond | 11-2 |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 9/26/2009 | W 38-28 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (5-4) | 10/10/2009 | W 21-17 at |
| 1-1 | 7-11 | 2-0 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Robert Morris | 5-6 |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (1-8) | 9/5/2009 | L 13-14 at |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Rutgers | 9-4 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 12/5/2009 | L 21-24 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Savannah St | 0-6 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (1-6) | 11/21/2009 | L 14-35 at |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (4-4) | 10/3/2009 | L 10-47 at |
| 2-0 | 5-10 | 0-2 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | South Florida | 8-5 |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (5-3) | 9/19/2009 | W 59-0 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (9-2) | 10/30/2009 | W 30-19 |
| 1-1 | 14-5 | 2-0 |
|
| 7-2 | — | 0 | (5 Common Ops) | 1 | Stony Brook | 5-5 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 10/3/2009 | W 52-14 |
| W 54-14 | 11/7/2009 | VMI (2-7) | 10/17/2009 | W 27-20 at |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (5-4) | 10/24/2009 | W 16-10 |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (4-3) | 10/31/2009 | W 24-14 at |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (4-4) | 11/14/2009 | L 27-30 1 at |
| 5-0 | 15-27 | 4-1 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Syracuse | 4-8 |
| L 20-33 at | 9/5/2009 | West Virginia (8-3) | 10/10/2009 | L 13-34 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | The Citadel | 4-7 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 9/26/2009 | W 46-21 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (2 Common Ops) | 0 | Towson | 2-9 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (5-4) | 9/19/2009 | W 21-17 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (4-5) | 11/21/2009 | L 12-43 at |
| 1-1 | 9-9 | 1-1 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Villanova | 14-1 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (5-4) | 10/17/2009 | W 27-0 at |
|
| 6-3 | — | 1 | (6 Common Ops) | 0 | VMI | 2-8 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (4-5) | 9/19/2009 | L 16-44 at |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (3-4) | 10/3/2009 | L 23-27 |
| W 58-13 | 10/17/2009 | Coastal Car (4-5) | 10/10/2009 | L 6-20 at |
| L 33-36 at | 11/21/2009 | Stony Brook (4-5) | 10/17/2009 | L 20-27 |
| W 55-19 | 10/31/2009 | Presbyterian (0-9) | 10/24/2009 | W 31-20 at |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (4-4) | 10/31/2009 | L 21-31 |
| 4-2 | 19-32 | 1-5 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Western Carolina | 2-9 |
| W 51-28 at | 11/14/2009 | Gardner Webb (3-4) | 9/12/2009 | L 20-27 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | William & Mary | 11-3 |
| L 10-24 | 9/26/2009 | James Madison (5-4) | 10/24/2009 | W 24-3 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Winston-Salem St | 1-10 |
| W 35-10 | 9/12/2009 | North Carolina Central (1-6) | 11/14/2009 | L 10-18 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Wofford | 3-8 |
| W 20-13 at | 10/24/2009 | Charleston So (5-3) | 9/12/2009 | W 42-14 |
|
| 7-3 | — | 0 | (1 Common Ops) | 0 | Yale | 4-6 |
| W 19-13 at | 9/19/2009 | Lafayette (7-2) | 10/3/2009 | L 14-31 |
|