8/31/2023 | Chowan | 0 | at | Barton | 41 | | | GSC |
| Virginia U-Lynchburg | 3 | at | Carson-Newman | 35 | | | None (Unk?) |
| Tusculum | 7 | at | Kennesaw St | 38 | | | @ ASUN (1AA) |
| Limestone | 19 | at | West Georgia | 21 | | | @ GSC |
9/1/2023 | Albany State GA | 7 | at | Wingate | 30 | | | SIAC |
9/2/2023 | Erskine | 17 | at | Allen | 24 | | | @ SIAC |
| Emory & Henry | 56 | at | Concord | 10 | | | @ MtnE |
| Catawba | 31 | at | Elizabeth City State | 23 | | | @ CIAA |
| St Augustine's | 7 | at | Lenoir-Rhyne | 45 | | | CIAA |
| Newberry | 14 | at | Shippensburg | 10 | | | @ PSAC |
| Union KY | 0 | at | Virginia-Wise | 48 | | | App (NAIA) |
9/7/2023 | Wingate | 10 | at | Mars Hill | 15 | | | |
9/8/2023 | Barton | 33 | at | Davidson | 31 | | | @ Pio (1AA) |
9/9/2023 | Emory & Henry | 37 | at | Bluefield St WV | 14 | | | @ CIAA |
| Livingstone | 15 | at | Catawba | 55 | | | CIAA |
| Carson-Newman | 0 | at | East Tennessee St | 42 | | | @ SoCon (1AA) |
| Lenoir-Rhyne | 24 | at | Fayetteville State | 10 | | | @ CIAA |
| West Alabama | 27 | at | Limestone | 13 | | | GSC |
| North Greenville | 24 | at | Newberry | 14 | | | GSC |
| Erskine | 7 | at | Shorter | 28 | | | @ GSC |
| Virginia-Wise | 0 | at | Thomas More | 37 | | | @ GMAC |
| Tusculum | 17 | at | Virginia State | 21 | | | @ CIAA |
9/16/2023 | Virginia-Wise | 24 | at | Barton | 28 | | | |
| Mars Hill | 35 | at | Catawba | 20 | | | |
| Erskine | 0 | at | Lenoir-Rhyne | 62 | | | |
| Carson-Newman | 14 | at | Limestone | 45 | | | |
| Emory & Henry | 23 | at | Newberry | 25 | 6OT | | |
| Tusculum | 23 | at | Wingate | 21 | | | |
9/23/2023 | Lenoir-Rhyne | 24 | at | Carson-Newman | 7 | | | |
| Wingate | 31 | at | Emory & Henry | 10 | | | |
| Newberry | 24 | at | Erskine | 17 | | | |
| Barton | 14 | at | Mars Hill | 16 | | | |
| Catawba | 21 | at | Tusculum | 35 | | | |
| Limestone | 38 | at | Virginia-Wise | 17 | | | |
9/30/2023 | Emory & Henry | 13 | at | Catawba | 30 | | | |
| Virginia-Wise | 3 | at | Lenoir-Rhyne | 56 | | | |
| Mars Hill | 23 | at | Limestone | 27 | | | |
| Carson-Newman | 34 | at | Newberry | 21 | | | |
| Barton | 17 | at | Tusculum | 14 | | | |
| Erskine | 0 | at | Wingate | 45 | | | |
10/7/2023 | Newberry | 17 | at | Barton | 34 | | | |
| Tusculum | 27 | at | Carson-Newman | 21 | | | |
| Wingate | 31 | at | Catawba | 13 | | | |
| Lenoir-Rhyne | 31 | at | Limestone | 28 | | | |
| Erskine | 3 | at | Mars Hill | 38 | | | |
| Emory & Henry | 41 | at | Virginia-Wise | 24 | | | |
10/14/2023 | Mars Hill | 24 | at | Emory & Henry | 14 | | | |
| Carson-Newman | 14 | at | Erskine | 10 | | | |
| Barton | 3 | at | Lenoir-Rhyne | 47 | | | |
| Catawba | 31 | at | Newberry | 38 | | | |
| Virginia-Wise | 7 | at | Tusculum | 35 | | | |
| Limestone | 17 | at | Wingate | 10 | | | |
10/21/2023 | Wingate | 38 | at | Barton | 24 | | | |
| Mars Hill | 21 | at | Carson-Newman | 17 | | | |
| Tusculum | 24 | at | Emory & Henry | 27 | OT | | |
| Catawba | 16 | at | Limestone | 27 | | | |
| Lenoir-Rhyne | 24 | at | Newberry | 10 | | | |
| Erskine | 23 | at | Virginia-Wise | 34 | | | |
10/28/2023 | Emory & Henry | 7 | at | Carson-Newman | 37 | | | |
| Barton | 27 | at | Catawba | 32 | | | |
| Tusculum | 52 | at | Erskine | 14 | | | |
| Newberry | 24 | at | Limestone | 28 | | | |
| Virginia-Wise | 24 | at | Mars Hill | 49 | | | |
| Lenoir-Rhyne | 30 | at | Wingate | 34 | | | |
11/4/2023 | Limestone | 33 | at | Barton | 28 | | | |
| Erskine | 14 | at | Emory & Henry | 56 | | | |
| Catawba | 7 | at | Lenoir-Rhyne | 28 | | | |
| Wingate | 21 | at | Newberry | 17 | | | |
| Mars Hill | 27 | at | Tusculum | 29 | | | |
| Carson-Newman | 52 | at | Virginia-Wise | 7 | | | |
11/11/2023 | Catawba | 24 | at | Carson-Newman | 14 | | | |
| Limestone | 47 | at | Emory & Henry | 29 | | | |
| Barton | 48 | at | Erskine | 14 | | | |
| Newberry | 14 | at | Mars Hill | 21 | | | |
| Lenoir-Rhyne | 48 | at | Tusculum | 7 | | | |
| Wingate | 27 | at | Virginia-Wise | 0 | | | |
11/18/2023 | Shepherd | 17 | at | Lenoir-Rhyne | 63 | | D2 Playoff Round 1 | PSAC |
| Limestone | 41 | at | Valdosta State | 62 | | D2 Playoff Round 1 | @ GSC |
11/25/2023 | Lenoir-Rhyne | 35 | at | Benedict | 25 | | D2 Playoffs Round 2 | @ SIAC |
12/2/2023 | Lenoir-Rhyne | 35 | at | Valdosta State | 7 | | D2 Championship - Quarterfinal | @ GSC |
12/9/2023 | Lenoir-Rhyne | 14 | at | Harding | 55 | | D2 Championship - Semifinal | @ GAC |