8/26/2023 | Indiana Wesleyan | 56 | at | Lawrence Tech | 7 | | | |
| Saint Ambrose | 34 | at | Taylor | 37 | | | |
9/2/2023 | Taylor | 14 | at | Concordia MI | 54 | | | |
| Marian IN | 40 | at | Judson | 6 | | | |
| Ave Maria | 19 | at | Lawrence Tech | 21 | | | Sun |
| Olivet Nazarene | 55 | at | Madonna | 0 | | | |
| North Central | 41 | at | Roosevelt | 7 | | | CCIW (D3) |
| Wisconsin-Stout | 35 | at | Saint Ambrose | 7 | | | WIAC (D3) |
| Waldorf | 7 | at | St Francis IL | 63 | | | NSAA |
| St Xavier | 45 | at | St Francis IN | 28 | | | |
9/9/2023 | Taylor | 13 | at | Butler | 41 | | | @ Pio (1AA) |
| Valparaiso | 22 | at | Indiana Wesleyan | 24 | | | Pio (1AA) |
| St Xavier | 21 | at | Marian IN | 28 | | | |
| Concordia MI | 34 | at | Olivet Nazarene | 28 | | | |
| Madonna | 0 | at | Quincy | 89 | | | @ GLV (D2) |
| Siena Heights | 10 | at | Roosevelt | 38 | | | |
| St Francis IN | 0 | at | St Francis IL | 17 | | | |
| Saint Ambrose | 26 | at | Upper Iowa | 45 | | | @ GLV (D2) |
9/16/2023 | Judson | 0 | at | Concordia MI | 54 | | | |
| Taylor | 20 | at | Dayton | 52 | | | @ Pio (1AA) |
| St Francis IL | 14 | at | Lawrence Tech | 12 | | | |
| Roosevelt | 42 | at | Madonna | 7 | | | |
| Olivet Nazarene | 14 | at | Marian IN | 45 | | | |
| Saint Ambrose | 14 | at | Siena Heights | 28 | | | |
| Indiana Wesleyan | 16 | at | St Xavier | 15 | | | |
9/23/2023 | Roosevelt | 14 | at | Indiana Wesleyan | 35 | | | |
| Siena Heights | 58 | at | Judson | 14 | | | |
| Lawrence Tech | 14 | at | Olivet Nazarene | 34 | | | |
| St Francis IN | 28 | at | Saint Ambrose | 9 | | | |
| Madonna | 7 | at | St Xavier | 31 | | | |
| St Francis IL | 24 | at | Taylor | 7 | | | |
9/30/2023 | Siena Heights | 12 | at | Indiana Wesleyan | 48 | | | |
| Olivet Nazarene | 58 | at | Judson | 14 | | | |
| St Francis IN | 44 | at | Madonna | 9 | | | |
| Lawrence Tech | 17 | at | Marian IN | 44 | | | |
| Saint Ambrose | 17 | at | Roosevelt | 30 | | | |
| St Xavier | 28 | at | St Francis IL | 21 | | | |
| Concordia MI | 24 | at | Wayne State MI | 23 | | | @ GLIAC (D2) |
10/7/2023 | Concordia MI | 24 | at | Lawrence Tech | 10 | | | |
| Marian IN | 41 | at | Madonna | 0 | | | |
| Central Methodist | 20 | at | Olivet Nazarene | 34 | | | HAAC |
| St Francis IL | 24 | at | Roosevelt | 28 | | | |
| Siena Heights | 28 | at | St Francis IN | 42 | | | |
| Judson | 6 | at | St Xavier | 58 | | | |
| Indiana Wesleyan | 42 | at | Taylor | 17 | | | |
10/14/2023 | Roosevelt | 7 | at | Bethel TN | 44 | | | @ MSC |
| Marian IN | 14 | at | Concordia MI | 7 | | | |
| Madonna | 0 | at | Indiana Wesleyan | 26 | | | |
| Taylor | 21 | at | Siena Heights | 24 | | | |
| Judson | 26 | at | St Francis IL | 56 | | | |
| Lawrence Tech | 7 | at | St Francis IN | 56 | | | |
| Saginaw Valley State | 32 | at | St Xavier | 10 | | | GLIAC (D2) |
10/21/2023 | Siena Heights | 24 | at | Concordia MI | 21 | | | |
| St Francis IN | 14 | at | Marian IN | 24 | | | |
| Roosevelt | 48 | at | Olivet Nazarene | 24 | | | |
| St Francis IL | 55 | at | Saint Ambrose | 0 | | | |
| Madonna | 14 | at | Taylor | 54 | | | |
10/28/2023 | Concordia MI | 67 | at | Madonna | 0 | | | |
| Judson | 28 | at | Roosevelt | 56 | | | |
| Lawrence Tech | 10 | at | Siena Heights | 31 | | | |
| St Xavier | 38 | at | Saint Ambrose | 13 | | | |
| Olivet Nazarene | 35 | at | St Francis IL | 7 | | | |
| Indiana Wesleyan | 52 | at | St Francis IN | 21 | | | |
| Marian IN | 34 | at | Taylor | 20 | | | |
11/4/2023 | Marian IN | 40 | at | Indiana Wesleyan | 42 | | | |
| Taylor | 37 | at | Lawrence Tech | 41 | | | |
| Madonna | 14 | at | Siena Heights | 77 | | | |
| Judson | 21 | at | Saint Ambrose | 41 | | | |
| Concordia MI | 24 | at | St Francis IN | 34 | | | |
| Olivet Nazarene | 21 | at | St Xavier | 38 | | | |
11/11/2023 | Indiana Wesleyan | 10 | at | Concordia MI | 21 | | | |
| St Francis IL | 37 | at | Judson | 0 | | | |
| Lawrence Tech | 66 | at | Madonna | 21 | | | |
| Siena Heights | 14 | at | Marian IN | 24 | | | |
| Saint Ambrose | 7 | at | Olivet Nazarene | 47 | | | |
| St Xavier | 35 | at | Roosevelt | 14 | | | |
| St Francis IN | 44 | at | Taylor | 31 | | | |
11/25/2023 | Morningside | 21 | at | Indiana Wesleyan | 24 | | NAIA Playoffs Round 2 | GPAC |
| St Xavier | 31 | at | Marian IN | 21 | | NAIA Playoffs Round 2 | |
12/2/2023 | Indiana Wesleyan | 21 | at | Georgetown KY | 31 | | NAIA Championship - Quarterfinal | @ MSC |
| St Xavier | 17 | at | Northwestern IA | 34 | | NAIA Championship - Quarterfinal | @ GPAC |