| #Votes | Rank | Teams Voting for Valparaiso |
| 1 | #209 | Campbell; |
| 13 | #210 | Georgia State; Connecticut; Hawaii; Kentucky; Louisiana Tech; New Mexico; Purdue; Western Michigan; Austin Peay; Columbia; Florida A&M; Georgetown; Presbyterian; |
| 8 | #211 | Lamar; Florida Intl; Idaho State; Indiana State; Massachusetts; Savannah State; VMI; Stetson; |
| 7 | #212 | Southern Miss; UTEP; Alabama A&M; Ark Pine Bluff; Mississippi Valley State; Northern Colorado; Texas Southern; |
| 2 | #213 | Miami-Ohio; New Mexico State; |
| 1 | #214 | Abilene Christian; |
| 1 | #215 | Incarnate Word; |
| 3 | #216 | Davidson; Valparaiso; Houston Baptist; |
| 1 | #217 | Grambling; |
| 3 | #226 | Army; Idaho; Temple; |
| 1 | #232 | Eastern Michigan; |
| 4 | #239 | Buffalo; Hampton; South Carolina State; Tennessee Tech; |
| 11 | #240 | Air Force; Akron; Nevada; North Carolina State; San Diego State; Wyoming; Delaware; James Madison; Maine; Towson; Old Dominion; |
| 74 | #241 | South Alabama; Arkansas; Arkansas State; Ball State; Baylor; Boise State; Boston College; Bowling Green; Central Michigan; Clemson; Duke; East Carolina; Florida; Florida State; Fresno State; Georgia Tech; Indiana; Iowa; Kansas State; Kent State; Louisville; Marshall; Maryland; Memphis; Miami-Florida; Michigan; Minnesota; Mississippi State; Navy; North Carolina; Northern Illinois; Northwestern; Ohio; Ohio State; Penn State; Pittsburgh; Rutgers; Syracuse; Tennessee; Toledo; Troy; Tulane; UCF; UL Lafayette; UL Monroe; UNLV; Virginia Tech; Wake Forest; West Virginia; Wisconsin; Alcorn State; Bethune-Cookman; Brown; Charleston Southern; Chattanooga; Coastal Carolina; Fordham; Georgia Southern; Gardner-Webb; Harvard; Howard; Liberty; North Carolina A&T; New Hampshire; Norfolk State; Pennsylvania; Princeton; Samford; Stony Brook; Texas State; Villanova; Western Kentucky; William & Mary; Wofford; |
| 19 | #242 | Alabama; Auburn; BYU; Georgia; LSU; Mississippi; Missouri; North Texas; Oklahoma State; South Carolina; Southern California; Texas A&M; Utah State; Vanderbilt; Virginia; Alabama State; Delaware State; Jackson State; Southern; |
| 23 | #243 | Arizona State; Colorado; Houston; Michigan State; Middle Tenn State; Notre Dame; Oklahoma; Oregon; San Jose State; SMU; Texas; Texas Tech; Washington State; Appalachian State; Eastern Kentucky; Lehigh; Montana; Montana State; Southern Utah; Sacred Heart; Southeastern Louisiana; Youngstown State; Bryant; |
| 10 | #244 | Arizona; Oregon State; Stanford; TCU; UCLA; Utah; Washington; Eastern Washington; Furman; Tennessee-Martin; |
| 7 | #245 | Colorado State; Lafayette; Morgan State; Sam Houston; St Francis PA; The Citadel; UNC-Charlotte; |
| 11 | #246 | Texas-San Antonio; Iowa State; Tulsa; Duquesne; Jacksonville State; Monmouth NJ; Rhode Island; Richmond; UC Davis; Wagner; North Carolina Central; |
| 26 | #247 | California; Cincinnati; Kansas; South Florida; Albany NY; Bucknell; Butler; Central Conn; Colgate; Cornell; Dartmouth; Dayton; Elon; Holy Cross; Illinois State; Marist; North Dakota State; Portland State; Prairie View; Robert Morris; Stephen F. Austin; Tennessee State; Western Carolina; Western Illinois; Yale; South Dakota; |
| 20 | #248 | Illinois; Nebraska; Rice; UAB; Cal Poly; Eastern Illinois; McNeese State; Murray State; Nicholls State; Northern Arizona; Northern Iowa; Northwestern State; South Dakota State; Sacramento State; San Diego; SE Missouri State; Missouri State; Southern Illinois; Weber State; Central Arkansas; |
| 2 | #249 | Florida Atlantic; Jacksonville; |
| 2 | #250 | Drake; Morehead State; |
| 2 | #251 | North Dakota; Mercer; |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 1 | Missouri | -170.6603122 | 0 | 170.6603122 |
| 2 | Alabama | -161.7700761 | 0 | 161.7700761 |
| 3 | Georgia | -148.2667897 | 0 | 148.2667897 |
| 4 | South Carolina | -135.2562207 | 0 | 135.2562207 |
| 5 | Clemson | -125.0104426 | 0 | 125.0104426 |
| 6 | Florida State | -121.9430285 | 0 | 121.9430285 |
| 7 | Auburn | -116.18912 | 0 | 116.18912 |
| 8 | Stanford | -115.2037329 | 0 | 115.2037329 |
| 9 | Oregon | -111.62247 | 0 | 111.62247 |
| 10 | LSU | -102.2940164 | 0 | 102.2940164 |
| 11 | Mississippi | -98.21418141 | 0 | 98.21418141 |
| 12 | Texas A&M | -95.78790195 | 0 | 95.78790195 |
| 13 | Notre Dame | -91.93872741 | 0 | 91.93872741 |
| 14 | Michigan | -90.08492973 | 0 | 90.08492973 |
| 15 | Oklahoma | -88.64519326 | 0 | 88.64519326 |
| 16 | Utah | -88.22953226 | 0 | 88.22953226 |
| 17 | Duke | -84.68481666 | 0 | 84.68481666 |
| 18 | Southern California | -84.27236466 | 0 | 84.27236466 |
| 19 | Tennessee | -83.62798063 | 0 | 83.62798063 |
| 20 | Ohio State | -82.85059415 | 0 | 82.85059415 |
| 21 | Miami-Florida | -81.27487262 | 0 | 81.27487262 |
| 22 | Fordham | -80.9338644 | 0 | 80.9338644 |
| 23 | Maine | -76.35574967 | 0 | 76.35574967 |
| 24 | BYU | -74.94126187 | 0 | 74.94126187 |
| 25 | Virginia Tech | -74.06233619 | 0 | 74.06233619 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 26 | Georgia Tech | -72.50776517 | 0 | 72.50776517 |
| 27 | Florida | -72.07088214 | 0 | 72.07088214 |
| 28 | Arizona State | -69.06850176 | 0 | 69.06850176 |
| 29 | Vanderbilt | -64.50332038 | 0 | 64.50332038 |
| 30 | Oregon State | -63.65840496 | 0 | 63.65840496 |
| 31 | Villanova | -63.52074093 | 0 | 63.52074093 |
| 32 | Toledo | -62.16178054 | 0 | 62.16178054 |
| 33 | Arizona | -60.05021779 | 0 | 60.05021779 |
| 34 | Lehigh | -58.52967161 | 0 | 58.52967161 |
| 35 | Texas | -57.84319186 | 0 | 57.84319186 |
| 36 | Pittsburgh | -55.63633783 | 0 | 55.63633783 |
| 37 | Navy | -55.44851664 | 0 | 55.44851664 |
| 38 | Penn State | -54.79555322 | 0 | 54.79555322 |
| 39 | Towson | -54.38180338 | 0 | 54.38180338 |
| 40 | Ball State | -53.70413421 | 0 | 53.70413421 |
| 41 | New Hampshire | -53.22574919 | 0 | 53.22574919 |
| 42 | Northern Illinois | -51.76193199 | 0 | 51.76193199 |
| 43 | Sacred Heart | -49.17181414 | 0 | 49.17181414 |
| 44 | Michigan State | -48.80904222 | 0 | 48.80904222 |
| 45 | UCLA | -47.14416076 | 0 | 47.14416076 |
| 46 | Northwestern | -46.89185135 | 0 | 46.89185135 |
| 47 | Baylor | -46.69553997 | 0 | 46.69553997 |
| 48 | Iowa | -44.84526487 | 0 | 44.84526487 |
| 49 | Washington State | -43.74357672 | 0 | 43.74357672 |
| 50 | Harvard | -41.96386121 | 0 | 41.96386121 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 51 | Eastern Washington | -41.91420059 | 0 | 41.91420059 |
| 52 | William & Mary | -41.68933788 | 0 | 41.68933788 |
| 53 | Texas Tech | -40.93409044 | 0 | 40.93409044 |
| 54 | Princeton | -40.75075856 | 0 | 40.75075856 |
| 55 | Minnesota | -40.15097317 | 0 | 40.15097317 |
| 56 | UCF | -40.00159019 | 0 | 40.00159019 |
| 57 | Boston College | -37.44330423 | 0 | 37.44330423 |
| 58 | Washington | -36.6422925 | 0 | 36.6422925 |
| 59 | North Dakota State | -36.51179318 | 0 | 36.51179318 |
| 60 | Delaware | -33.35703732 | 0 | 33.35703732 |
| 61 | UL Lafayette | -32.90071604 | 0 | 32.90071604 |
| 62 | Bucknell | -32.61581527 | 0 | 32.61581527 |
| 63 | Maryland | -32.54951937 | 0 | 32.54951937 |
| 64 | Virginia | -32.38638064 | 0 | 32.38638064 |
| 65 | Central Michigan | -31.89819539 | 0 | 31.89819539 |
| 66 | Western Kentucky | -31.49458301 | 0 | 31.49458301 |
| 67 | St Francis PA | -31.35133515 | 0 | 31.35133515 |
| 68 | West Virginia | -30.40147622 | 0 | 30.40147622 |
| 69 | Indiana | -29.84993367 | 0 | 29.84993367 |
| 70 | James Madison | -29.60190988 | 0 | 29.60190988 |
| 71 | Syracuse | -29.27938417 | 0 | 29.27938417 |
| 72 | South Alabama | -28.81101885 | 0 | 28.81101885 |
| 73 | Tulane | -28.71036105 | 0 | 28.71036105 |
| 74 | Bryant | -28.41563345 | 0 | 28.41563345 |
| 75 | Oklahoma State | -27.85243076 | 0 | 27.85243076 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 76 | Youngstown State | -27.80384474 | 0 | 27.80384474 |
| 77 | Kansas State | -27.46656692 | 0 | 27.46656692 |
| 78 | Troy | -27.43718603 | 0 | 27.43718603 |
| 79 | Stony Brook | -26.29651472 | 0 | 26.29651472 |
| 80 | Fresno State | -26.02586885 | 0 | 26.02586885 |
| 81 | North Texas | -26.01988947 | 0 | 26.01988947 |
| 82 | Lafayette | -25.6026013 | 0 | 25.6026013 |
| 83 | Holy Cross | -25.44513191 | 0 | 25.44513191 |
| 84 | Brown | -24.89965585 | 0 | 24.89965585 |
| 85 | Wisconsin | -24.43068188 | 0 | 24.43068188 |
| 86 | Montana State | -23.07611601 | 0 | 23.07611601 |
| 87 | Pennsylvania | -22.17094274 | 0 | 22.17094274 |
| 88 | Arkansas | -21.97621371 | 0 | 21.97621371 |
| 89 | Monmouth NJ | -21.94326952 | 0 | 21.94326952 |
| 90 | Coastal Carolina | -21.81536752 | 0 | 21.81536752 |
| 91 | Eastern Illinois | -21.74694669 | 0 | 21.74694669 |
| 92 | Wagner | -21.68997979 | 0 | 21.68997979 |
| 93 | Wake Forest | -21.60360262 | 0 | 21.60360262 |
| 94 | Sam Houston | -21.44708769 | 0 | 21.44708769 |
| 95 | UNLV | -20.13183679 | 0 | 20.13183679 |
| 96 | Ohio | -19.71365091 | 0 | 19.71365091 |
| 97 | Louisville | -19.20240034 | 0 | 19.20240034 |
| 98 | North Carolina | -19.0730204 | 0 | 19.0730204 |
| 99 | McNeese State | -18.76036096 | 0 | 18.76036096 |
| 100 | Georgia Southern | -18.51698823 | 0 | 18.51698823 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 101 | Mississippi State | -18.31163996 | 0 | 18.31163996 |
| 102 | Southeastern Louisiana | -18.11078045 | 0 | 18.11078045 |
| 103 | Samford | -17.80517375 | 0 | 17.80517375 |
| 104 | Northern Arizona | -17.69194254 | 0 | 17.69194254 |
| 105 | Colgate | -17.55749366 | 0 | 17.55749366 |
| 106 | Duquesne | -17.34924491 | 0 | 17.34924491 |
| 107 | East Carolina | -17.27276263 | 0 | 17.27276263 |
| 108 | Central Conn | -17.2128358 | 0 | 17.2128358 |
| 109 | Yale | -16.73919186 | 0 | 16.73919186 |
| 110 | North Carolina State | -16.73640554 | 0 | 16.73640554 |
| 111 | UL Monroe | -16.45980962 | 0 | 16.45980962 |
| 112 | Texas State | -16.43776147 | 0 | 16.43776147 |
| 113 | South Dakota State | -16.23260196 | 0 | 16.23260196 |
| 114 | TCU | -15.97780451 | 0 | 15.97780451 |
| 115 | Boise State | -15.21645854 | 0 | 15.21645854 |
| 116 | Rutgers | -15.19833829 | 0 | 15.19833829 |
| 117 | Southern Utah | -15.13958547 | 0 | 15.13958547 |
| 118 | Dayton | -14.70070693 | 0 | 14.70070693 |
| 119 | Liberty | -14.67914149 | 0 | 14.67914149 |
| 120 | Missouri State | -14.44731139 | 0 | 14.44731139 |
| 121 | Buffalo | -14.4445643 | 0 | 14.4445643 |
| 122 | Cornell | -14.38181944 | 0 | 14.38181944 |
| 123 | Bowling Green | -13.80529553 | 0 | 13.80529553 |
| 124 | Rhode Island | -13.78765693 | 0 | 13.78765693 |
| 125 | South Dakota | -13.29706825 | 0 | 13.29706825 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 126 | Southern Illinois | -13.23189473 | 0 | 13.23189473 |
| 127 | Akron | -12.99855372 | 0 | 12.99855372 |
| 128 | Houston | -12.70406175 | 0 | 12.70406175 |
| 129 | SMU | -12.43625598 | 0 | 12.43625598 |
| 130 | Nebraska | -12.20703249 | 0 | 12.20703249 |
| 131 | Old Dominion | -12.16754022 | 0 | 12.16754022 |
| 132 | Tennessee State | -12.11770043 | 0 | 12.11770043 |
| 133 | Arkansas State | -11.84439711 | 0 | 11.84439711 |
| 134 | Wofford | -11.74955224 | 0 | 11.74955224 |
| 135 | Stephen F. Austin | -11.61958463 | 0 | 11.61958463 |
| 136 | Montana | -11.52101186 | 0 | 11.52101186 |
| 137 | Central Arkansas | -11.50547281 | 0 | 11.50547281 |
| 138 | Colorado | -10.63453181 | 0 | 10.63453181 |
| 139 | Gardner-Webb | -10.57768036 | 0 | 10.57768036 |
| 140 | Tennessee-Martin | -10.4247331 | 0 | 10.4247331 |
| 141 | Murray State | -10.0063192 | 0 | 10.0063192 |
| 142 | Robert Morris | -9.967864692 | 0 | 9.967864692 |
| 143 | Appalachian State | -9.26720643 | 0 | 9.26720643 |
| 144 | Northern Iowa | -9.239216283 | 0 | 9.239216283 |
| 145 | Illinois State | -9.099562898 | 0 | 9.099562898 |
| 146 | Air Force | -9.017789409 | 0 | 9.017789409 |
| 147 | Bethune-Cookman | -8.698512301 | 0 | 8.698512301 |
| 148 | Utah State | -8.442103326 | 0 | 8.442103326 |
| 149 | Charleston Southern | -8.218693435 | 0 | 8.218693435 |
| 150 | Dartmouth | -7.837816626 | 0 | 7.837816626 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 151 | Albany NY | -7.733570665 | 0 | 7.733570665 |
| 152 | Marist | -7.554663196 | 0 | 7.554663196 |
| 153 | Eastern Kentucky | -7.507304847 | 0 | 7.507304847 |
| 154 | Western Illinois | -7.414862439 | 0 | 7.414862439 |
| 155 | Northwestern State | -7.377424374 | 0 | 7.377424374 |
| 156 | Illinois | -7.343695864 | 0 | 7.343695864 |
| 157 | Nevada | -6.789542437 | 0 | 6.789542437 |
| 158 | Jacksonville State | -6.697183594 | 0 | 6.697183594 |
| 159 | UC Davis | -6.552853227 | 0 | 6.552853227 |
| 160 | Kent State | -6.4290016 | 0 | 6.4290016 |
| 160 | Richmond | -6.4290016 | 0 | 6.4290016 |
| 162 | Middle Tenn State | -6.290790647 | 0 | 6.290790647 |
| 163 | Chattanooga | -6.262199074 | 0 | 6.262199074 |
| 164 | Marshall | -6.174897209 | 0 | 6.174897209 |
| 165 | Furman | -6.039058596 | 0 | 6.039058596 |
| 166 | Cal Poly | -5.912957743 | 0 | 5.912957743 |
| 167 | Kansas | -5.848645717 | 0 | 5.848645717 |
| 168 | North Carolina A&T | -5.375035107 | 0 | 5.375035107 |
| 169 | Weber State | -5.127931491 | 0 | 5.127931491 |
| 169 | Prairie View | -5.127931491 | 0 | 5.127931491 |
| 171 | Memphis | -5.079019517 | 0 | 5.079019517 |
| 172 | Rice | -5.022116512 | 0 | 5.022116512 |
| 173 | San Jose State | -4.978145957 | 0 | 4.978145957 |
| 174 | South Carolina State | -4.85242632 | 0 | 4.85242632 |
| 175 | San Diego | -4.674401656 | 0 | 4.674401656 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 176 | UNC-Charlotte | -4.610345721 | 0 | 4.610345721 |
| 177 | The Citadel | -4.551108435 | 0 | 4.551108435 |
| 178 | Jackson State | -4.458993629 | 0 | 4.458993629 |
| 179 | Colorado State | -4.42166397 | 0 | 4.42166397 |
| 180 | SE Missouri State | -4.409958765 | 0 | 4.409958765 |
| 181 | Wyoming | -3.997494936 | 0 | 3.997494936 |
| 182 | Hampton | -3.610477656 | 0 | 3.610477656 |
| 183 | Cincinnati | -3.347557485 | 0 | 3.347557485 |
| 184 | Portland State | -3.329617098 | 0 | 3.329617098 |
| 185 | UAB | -3.259098291 | 0 | 3.259098291 |
| 185 | Nicholls State | -3.259098291 | 0 | 3.259098291 |
| 187 | San Diego State | -2.955482274 | 0 | 2.955482274 |
| 188 | Sacramento State | -2.76387924 | 0 | 2.76387924 |
| 189 | Alabama State | -2.705701858 | 0 | 2.705701858 |
| 190 | Elon | -2.633901715 | 0 | 2.633901715 |
| 191 | Delaware State | -2.517415687 | 0 | 2.517415687 |
| 192 | Southern | -2.26387924 | 0 | 2.26387924 |
| 193 | North Carolina Central | -2.179634839 | 0 | 2.179634839 |
| 194 | Florida Atlantic | -2.094507158 | 0 | 2.094507158 |
| 195 | Tulsa | -1.975508332 | 0 | 1.975508332 |
| 196 | Mercer | -1.625 | 0 | 1.625 |
| 197 | Tennessee Tech | -1.566216722 | 0 | 1.566216722 |
| 198 | South Florida | -1.478530139 | 0 | 1.478530139 |
| 199 | California | -1.468574747 | 0 | 1.468574747 |
| 200 | Texas-San Antonio | -1.440960541 | 0 | 1.440960541 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 201 | Drake | -1.25 | 0 | 1.25 |
| 202 | Western Carolina | -1.145951554 | 0 | 1.145951554 |
| 203 | North Dakota | -1 | 0 | 1 |
| 203 | Morehead State | -1 | 0 | 1 |
| 205 | Alcorn State | -0.999883056 | 0 | 0.999883056 |
| 206 | Morgan State | -0.943966851 | 0 | 0.943966851 |
| 207 | Iowa State | -0.883914813 | 0 | 0.883914813 |
| 208 | Butler | -0.875 | 0 | 0.875 |
| 209 | Jacksonville | -0.5 | 0 | 0.5 |
| 210 | Army | -0.482410401 | 0 | 0.482410401 |
| 211 | Norfolk State | -0.407440409 | 0 | 0.407440409 |
| 211 | Howard | -0.407440409 | 0 | 0.407440409 |
| 213 | Temple | -0.207079172 | 0 | 0.207079172 |
| 214 | Eastern Michigan | -0.17517294 | 0 | 0.17517294 |
| 215 | Idaho | -0.088459194 | 0 | 0.088459194 |
| 216 | Purdue | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Kentucky | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Connecticut | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Florida Intl | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Southern Miss | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Louisiana Tech | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | UTEP | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | New Mexico State | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Massachusetts | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Miami-Ohio | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 216 | Western Michigan | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | New Mexico | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Hawaii | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Georgia State | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Idaho State | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Northern Colorado | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Presbyterian | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | VMI | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Abilene Christian | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Incarnate Word | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Houston Baptist | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Columbia | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Florida A&M | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Savannah State | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Indiana State | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Austin Peay | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Georgetown | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Valparaiso | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Stetson | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Davidson | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Lamar | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Alabama A&M | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Mississippi Valley State | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Texas Southern | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 216 | Ark Pine Bluff | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Rank | Team | ΔPaths | Valparaiso → | → Valparaiso |
| 216 | Grambling | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 252 | Campbell | 1 | 1 | 0 |