| 9/3/2011 | Case Western Reserve Spartans 24 @ John Carroll 17 | |
| 9/17/2011 | John Carroll 7 @ Mount Union Purple Raiders 58 | † |
| 9/24/2011 | John Carroll 37 @ Marietta Pioneers 35 | † |
| 10/1/2011 | Otterbein Cardinals 41 @ John Carroll 47 | † |
| 10/8/2011 | John Carroll 44 @ Wilmington Quakers 7 | † |
| 10/15/2011 | Muskingum Muskies 14 @ John Carroll 13 | † |
| 10/22/2011 | John Carroll 21 @ Ohio Northern Polar Bears 24 | † |
| 10/29/2011 | Capital Crusaders 24 @ John Carroll 37 | † |
| 11/5/2011 | Heidelberg Fighting Student Princes 41 @ John Carroll 28 | † |
| 11/12/2011 | John Carroll 37 @ Baldwin-Wallace Yellow Jackets 45 | † |