Pioneer Conference schedule & results
9/1/2011 | Kentucky Christian NAIA | 0 | at | Morehead State 1AA | 67 | | |
| Drake 1AA | 0 | at | North Dakota 1AA | 16 | | |
9/3/2011 | San Diego 1AA | 42 | at | Azusa Pacific NAIA | 40 | | |
| Albion D3 | 17 | at | Butler 1AA | 31 | | |
| Davidson 1AA | 16 | at | Georgetown 1AA | 40 | | |
| Campbell 1AA | 14 | at | Old Dominion 1AA | 41 | | |
| Dayton 1AA | 19 | at | Robert Morris 1AA | 13 | | |
| Marist 1AA | 20 | at | Sacred Heart 1AA | 7 | | |
| Jacksonville 1AA | 9 | at | The Citadel 1AA | 31 | | |
| Franklin D3 | 49 | at | Valparaiso 1AA | 35 | | |
9/10/2011 | Marist 1AA | 14 | at | Bucknell 1AA | 28 | | |
| Apprentice D3 | 0 | at | Campbell 1AA | 76 | | |
| Lenoir-Rhyne D2 | 10 | at | Davidson 1AA | 28 | | |
| Duquesne 1AA | 22 | at | Dayton 1AA | 13 | | |
| Grand View NAIA | 21 | at | Drake 1AA | 28 | OT | |
| Morehead State 1AA | 21 | at | Illinois State 1AA | 52 | | |
| Butler 1AA | 34 | at | Indiana State 1AA | 48 | | |
| Western New Mexico D2 | 10 | at | San Diego 1AA | 30 | | |
| Jacksonville 1AA | 21 | at | Western Illinois 1AA | 35 | | |
| Valparaiso 1AA | 13 | at | Youngstown State 1AA | 77 | | |
9/17/2011 | Marist 1AA | 10 | at | Dayton 1AA | 24 | | |
| Missouri S&T D2 | 23 | at | Drake 1AA | 27 | | |
| Valparaiso 1AA | 14 | at | Duquesne 1AA | 49 | | |
| Charleston Southern 1AA | 30 | at | Jacksonville 1AA | 37 | | |
| Morehead State 1AA | 49 | at | St Francis PA 1AA | 50 | | |
| Butler 1AA | 23 | at | Taylor NAIA | 6 | | |
| San Diego 1AA | 3 | at | UC Davis 1AA | 31 | | |
9/24/2011 | Drake 1AA | 24 | at | Butler 1AA | 14 | | |
| Jacksonville 1AA | 57 | at | Campbell 1AA | 21 | | |
| Dayton 1AA | 17 | at | Central State D2 | 7 | | |
| Johnson C Smith D2 | 7 | at | Davidson 1AA | 35 | | |
| Georgetown 1AA | 52 | at | Marist 1AA | 28 | | |
| San Diego 1AA | 48 | at | Morehead State 1AA | 44 | | |
10/1/2011 | Butler 1AA | 29 | at | Dayton 1AA | 27 | | |
| Campbell 1AA | 14 | at | Drake 1AA | 31 | | |
| Jacksonville 1AA | 21 | at | Marist 1AA | 9 | | |
| Davidson 1AA | 0 | at | San Diego 1AA | 42 | | |
| Morehead State 1AA | 38 | at | Valparaiso 1AA | 14 | | |
10/8/2011 | Butler 1AA | 23 | at | Campbell 1AA | 38 | | |
| Marist 1AA | 13 | at | Davidson 1AA | 9 | | |
| Dayton 1AA | 26 | at | Jacksonville 1AA | 34 | | |
| Drake 1AA | 41 | at | Morehead State 1AA | 26 | | |
| San Diego 1AA | 56 | at | Valparaiso 1AA | 14 | | |
10/15/2011 | Valparaiso 1AA | 14 | at | Butler 1AA | 42 | | |
| Davidson 1AA | 0 | at | Dayton 1AA | 28 | | |
| Morehead State 1AA | 14 | at | Jacksonville 1AA | 50 | | |
| Campbell 1AA | 35 | at | Marist 1AA | 21 | | |
| Drake 1AA | 24 | at | San Diego 1AA | 31 | | |
10/22/2011 | Marist 1AA | 28 | at | Butler 1AA | 10 | | |
| San Diego 1AA | 24 | at | Campbell 1AA | 48 | | |
| Valparaiso 1AA | 0 | at | Drake 1AA | 50 | | |
| Davidson 1AA | 13 | at | Jacksonville 1AA | 56 | | |
| Dayton 1AA | 30 | at | Morehead State 1AA | 28 | | |
10/29/2011 | Campbell 1AA | 26 | at | Davidson 1AA | 20 | 3 OT | |
| Drake 1AA | 23 | at | Marist 1AA | 13 | | |
| Dayton 1AA | 49 | at | Valparaiso 1AA | 10 | | |
11/5/2011 | Davidson 1AA | 7 | at | Butler 1AA | 17 | | |
| Morehead State 1AA | 31 | at | Campbell 1AA | 41 | | |
| San Diego 1AA | 31 | at | Dayton 1AA | 28 | | |
| Jacksonville 1AA | 24 | at | Drake 1AA | 31 | | |
| Valparaiso 1AA | 7 | at | Marist 1AA | 30 | | |
11/12/2011 | Morehead State 1AA | 24 | at | Davidson 1AA | 28 | | |
| Dayton 1AA | 14 | at | Drake 1AA | 37 | | |
| Butler 1AA | 24 | at | Jacksonville 1AA | 34 | | |
| Marist 1AA | 7 | at | San Diego 1AA | 13 | | |
| Campbell 1AA | 31 | at | Valparaiso 1AA | 34 | | |
11/19/2011 | Valparaiso 1AA | 22 | at | Davidson 1AA | 30 | | |
| Campbell 1AA | 35 | at | Georgia State 1AA | 42 | | |
| Butler 1AA | 35 | at | Morehead State 1AA | 55 | | |
| Jacksonville 1AA | 14 | at | San Diego 1AA | 23 | | |