Muskingum

4-6 (4-5 Ohio Athletic)

9/5/2009 Muskingum 7 @ Defiance 13
9/19/2009 Otterbein 38 @ Muskingum 21 †
9/26/2009 Muskingum 14 @ Mount Union 45 †
10/3/2009 Ohio Northern 37 @ Muskingum 34 †
10/10/2009 Wilmington 7 @ Muskingum 24 †
10/17/2009 Muskingum 14 @ Baldwin-Wallace 27 †
10/24/2009 Marietta 12 @ Muskingum 15 †
10/31/2009 Capital 35 @ Muskingum 7 †
11/7/2009 Muskingum 34 @ John Carroll 31 †
11/14/2009 Muskingum 31 @ Heidelberg 28 †