Colby

4-4 (4-4 New England Small College Athletic Association)

9/26/2009 Williams 23 @ Colby 19 †
10/3/2009 Colby 0 @ Middlebury 45 †
10/10/2009 Colby 16 @ Wesleyan 13 †
10/17/2009 Amherst 23 @ Colby 13 †
10/24/2009 Colby 16 @ Hamilton 0 †
10/31/2009 Bates 27 @ Colby 34 †
11/7/2009 Tufts 31 @ Colby 34 †
11/14/2009 Colby 27 @ Bowdoin 32 †