9/5/2009 | Mount Union 52 @ St John Fisher 10 | |
9/12/2009 | Buffalo St 7 @ St John Fisher 55 | |
9/19/2009 | Rochester 33 @ St John Fisher 36 | |
9/26/2009 | St John Fisher 20 @ Salisbury 38 | |
10/10/2009 | St John Fisher 40 @ Ithaca 17 | † |
10/17/2009 | Utica 17 @ St John Fisher 34 | † |
10/24/2009 | Alfred 31 @ St John Fisher 28 | † |
11/7/2009 | St John Fisher 34 @ Springfield 7 | † |
11/14/2009 | St John Fisher 56 @ Hartwick 13 | † |
11/21/2009 | Cortland St 20 @ St John Fisher 34 (D3) |