| 9/2/2023 | Ohio Wesleyan (5-5) | 35 | at | Otterbein | 21 | NCA | ||
| 9/9/2023 | Muskingum (4-6,3-6) | 27 | at | Otterbein | 14 | |||
| 9/16/2023 | Wilmington (3-7,2-7) | 47 | at | Otterbein | 21 | |||
| 9/23/2023 | Otterbein | 0 | at | Marietta (8-2,7-2) | 50 | |||
| 9/30/2023 | Otterbein | 31 | at | Capital (1-9,1-8) | 35 | |||
| 10/14/2023 | Otterbein | 8 | at | Heidelberg (6-4,5-4) | 28 | |||
| 10/21/2023 | Baldwin-Wallace (6-4,6-3) | 24 | at | Otterbein | 0 | |||
| 10/28/2023 | Otterbein | 14 | at | Mount Union (11-1,9-0) | 51 | |||
| 11/4/2023 | Otterbein | 6 | at | Ohio Northern (4-6,4-5) | 49 | |||
| 11/11/2023 | John Carroll (8-2,8-1) | 37 | at | Otterbein | 22 |
| vs Otterbein | vs Other Opponents | Otterbein compared to OOs | |
| Record: | 10-0 | 46-46 | |
| Points Scored: | 38.30 | 30.45 | -7.85 |
| Points Allowed: | 13.70 | 28.80 | -15.10 |
| Margin: | 24.60 | 1.65 | -22.95 |
| Total Points: | 52.00 | 59.25 | -7.25 |