| 9/2/2023 | Averett | 34 | at | Apprentice | 14 | @ None (Unk?) | ||
| Susquehanna | 51 | at | Bridgewater VA | 19 | LM | |||
| Greensboro | 21 | at | Guilford | 36 | USASC | |||
| Wabash | 29 | at | Hampden-Sydney | 28 | NCA | |||
| Ferrum | 20 | at | Muskingum | 31 | @ OAC | |||
| Randolph-Macon | 51 | at | North Carolina Wesleyan | 9 | @ USASC | |||
| Methodist | 29 | at | Shenandoah | 44 | USASC | |||
| Salisbury | 28 | at | Washington and Lee | 7 | NJAC | |||
| 9/9/2023 | Greensboro | 7 | at | Averett | 34 | USASC | ||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | 0 | at | Ferrum | 34 | USASC | |||
| Brevard | 17 | at | Hampden-Sydney | 31 | USASC | |||
| Guilford | 39 | at | Methodist | 21 | @ USASC | |||
| Catholic | 14 | at | Randolph-Macon | 59 | LM | |||
| Bridgewater VA | 35 | at | Southern Virginia | 9 | @ USASC | |||
| 9/16/2023 | Averett | 17 | at | Brevard | 14 | @ USASC | ||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | 12 | at | Bridgewater VA | 41 | USASC | |||
| LaGrange | 10 | at | Ferrum | 13 | USASC | |||
| Hampden-Sydney | 58 | at | Greensboro | 28 | @ USASC | |||
| Guilford | 14 | at | Huntingdon AL | 40 | @ USASC | |||
| Maryville | 27 | at | Shenandoah | 20 | USASC | |||
| Randolph-Macon | 51 | at | Southern Virginia | 10 | @ USASC | |||
| Methodist | 14 | at | Washington and Lee | 54 | USASC | |||
| 9/23/2023 | Juniata | 7 | at | Shenandoah | 48 | LM | ||
| 9/24/2023 | Washington and Lee | 28 | at | Apprentice | 9 | @ None (Unk?) | ||
| 9/30/2023 | Washington and Lee | 25 | at | Averett | 20 | |||
| Shenandoah | 38 | at | Ferrum | 3 | ||||
| Randolph-Macon | 70 | at | Guilford | 14 | ||||
| Bridgewater VA | 39 | at | Hampden-Sydney | 38 | ||||
| 10/7/2023 | Ferrum | 10 | at | Hampden-Sydney | 48 | |||
| Averett | 7 | at | Randolph-Macon | 59 | ||||
| Bridgewater VA | 24 | at | Shenandoah | 10 | ||||
| Guilford | 25 | at | Washington and Lee | 48 | ||||
| 10/14/2023 | Hampden-Sydney | 31 | at | Averett | 28 | |||
| Randolph-Macon | 38 | at | Bridgewater VA | 3 | ||||
| Shenandoah | 31 | at | Guilford | 20 | ||||
| Ferrum | 16 | at | Washington and Lee | 41 | ||||
| 10/21/2023 | Bridgewater VA | 53 | at | Averett | 24 | |||
| Guilford | 0 | at | Ferrum | 28 | ||||
| Washington and Lee | 21 | at | Hampden-Sydney | 17 | ||||
| Shenandoah | 13 | at | Randolph-Macon | 48 | ||||
| 10/28/2023 | Ferrum | 16 | at | Bridgewater VA | 48 | |||
| Hampden-Sydney | 42 | at | Guilford | 21 | ||||
| Washington and Lee | 12 | at | Randolph-Macon | 35 | ||||
| Averett | 35 | at | Shenandoah | 49 | ||||
| 11/4/2023 | Randolph-Macon | 49 | at | Ferrum | 16 | |||
| Averett | 34 | at | Guilford | 13 | ||||
| Shenandoah | 25 | at | Hampden-Sydney | 26 | OT | |||
| Bridgewater VA | 21 | at | Washington and Lee | 31 | ||||
| 11/11/2023 | Ferrum | 10 | at | Averett | 38 | |||
| Guilford | 15 | at | Bridgewater VA | 47 | ||||
| Hampden-Sydney | 10 | at | Randolph-Macon | 49 | ||||
| Washington and Lee | 40 | at | Shenandoah | 21 | ||||
| 11/18/2023 | Christopher Newport | 20 | at | Randolph-Macon | 28 | D3 Playoff Round 1 | NJAC | |
| Lycoming | 20 | at | Washington and Lee | 17 | Cape Charles Bowl | LM | ||
| Bridgewater VA | 17 | at | Wilkes | 35 | Cape Henry Bowl | @ LM | ||
| 11/25/2023 | Ithaca | 0 | at | Randolph-Macon | 46 | D3 Playoffs Round 2 | LL | |
| 12/2/2023 | Randolph-Macon | 39 | at | Johns Hopkins | 36 | D3 Championship - Quarterfinal | @ Cen | |
| 12/9/2023 | Cortland | 49 | at | Randolph-Macon | 14 | D3 Championship - Semifinal | E8 |