| 8/31/2023 | Ashland | 17 | at | Indiana PA | 24 | @ PSAC | ||
| Glenville State | 44 | at | Northwood | 9 | MtnE | |||
| West Liberty | 21 | at | Walsh | 24 | MtnE | |||
| 9/1/2023 | Kentucky Wesleyan | 3 | at | West Florida | 35 | @ GSC | ||
| 9/2/2023 | Thomas More | 17 | at | Davenport | 31 | @ GLIAC | ||
| Truman State | 20 | at | Findlay | 10 | GLV | |||
| Hillsdale | 20 | at | Indianapolis | 39 | @ GLV | |||
| Franklin Pierce | 26 | at | Lake Erie | 10 | NE10 | |||
| Ohio Dominican | 21 | at | Notre Dame OH | 23 | @ MtnE | |||
| McKendree | 14 | at | Tiffin | 79 | GLV | |||
| 9/9/2023 | Ferris State | 38 | at | Ashland | 28 | GLIAC | ||
| Walsh | 14 | at | Johnson C Smith | 9 | @ CIAA | |||
| Hillsdale | 20 | at | Michigan Tech | 45 | @ GLIAC | |||
| Lake Erie | 24 | at | Northern Michigan | 21 | @ GLIAC | |||
| Winston-Salem State | 14 | at | Ohio Dominican | 26 | CIAA | |||
| Findlay | 40 | at | Pace | 25 | @ NE10 | |||
| Northwood | 8 | at | Saginaw Valley State | 31 | @ GLIAC | |||
| Tiffin | 42 | at | Saint Anselm | 7 | @ NE10 | |||
| Virginia-Wise | 0 | at | Thomas More | 37 | SAC | |||
| Kentucky Wesleyan | 41 | at | William Jewell | 34 | @ GLV | |||
| 9/16/2023 | Hillsdale | 14 | at | Ashland | 38 | |||
| Walsh | 28 | at | Kentucky Wesleyan | 31 | ||||
| Findlay | 45 | at | Lake Erie | 3 | ||||
| Tiffin | 34 | at | Northwood | 27 | ||||
| Ohio Dominican | 17 | at | Thomas More | 18 | ||||
| 9/23/2023 | Findlay | 31 | at | Hillsdale | 21 | |||
| Ohio Dominican | 10 | at | Kentucky Wesleyan | 13 | ||||
| Lake Erie | 14 | at | Northwood | 68 | ||||
| Ashland | 30 | at | Tiffin | 55 | ||||
| Thomas More | 26 | at | Walsh | 10 | ||||
| 9/30/2023 | Kentucky Wesleyan | 21 | at | Findlay | 27 | |||
| Northwood | 18 | at | Hillsdale | 40 | ||||
| Walsh | 30 | at | Lake Erie | 16 | ||||
| Ashland | 20 | at | Ohio Dominican | 6 | ||||
| Tiffin | 47 | at | Thomas More | 9 | ||||
| 10/7/2023 | Walsh | 7 | at | Ashland | 21 | |||
| Thomas More | 36 | at | Kentucky Wesleyan | 28 | ||||
| Findlay | 30 | at | Northwood | 33 | ||||
| Lake Erie | 17 | at | Ohio Dominican | 41 | ||||
| Hillsdale | 21 | at | Tiffin | 35 | ||||
| 10/14/2023 | Thomas More | 10 | at | Findlay | 38 | |||
| Kentucky Wesleyan | 14 | at | Hillsdale | 44 | ||||
| Tiffin | 50 | at | Lake Erie | 0 | ||||
| Ashland | 35 | at | Northwood | 3 | ||||
| Ohio Dominican | 12 | at | Walsh | 10 | ||||
| 10/21/2023 | Lake Erie | 19 | at | Ashland | 31 | |||
| Northwood | 0 | at | Ohio Dominican | 15 | ||||
| Hillsdale | 35 | at | Thomas More | 33 | ||||
| Kentucky Wesleyan | 12 | at | Tiffin | 37 | ||||
| Findlay | 23 | at | Walsh | 0 | ||||
| 10/28/2023 | Thomas More | 20 | at | Ashland | 28 | |||
| Ohio Dominican | 3 | at | Findlay | 24 | ||||
| Lake Erie | 21 | at | Hillsdale | 52 | ||||
| Northwood | 28 | at | Kentucky Wesleyan | 13 | ||||
| Walsh | 13 | at | Tiffin | 40 | ||||
| 11/4/2023 | Findlay | 35 | at | Ashland | 37 | |||
| Kentucky Wesleyan | 43 | at | Lake Erie | 37 | OT | |||
| Thomas More | 20 | at | Northwood | 24 | ||||
| Tiffin | 44 | at | Ohio Dominican | 10 | ||||
| Hillsdale | 28 | at | Walsh | 3 | ||||
| 11/11/2023 | Tiffin | 26 | at | Findlay | 7 | |||
| Ohio Dominican | 17 | at | Hillsdale | 35 | ||||
| Ashland | 56 | at | Kentucky Wesleyan | 23 | ||||
| Lake Erie | 6 | at | Thomas More | 44 | ||||
| Northwood | 31 | at | Walsh | 24 | ||||
| 11/25/2023 | Slippery Rock | 45 | at | Tiffin | 35 | D2 Playoffs Round 2 | PSAC | |
| 12/1/2023 | McKendree | 20 | vs | Ashland | 23 | America's Crossroads Bowl - Hammond IN | vs GLV |