| 9/3/2016 | Aurora (6-4) | 11 | at | Carthage | 51 | NAC | ||
| 9/10/2016 | Carthage | 40 | at | Bethel MN (5-5) | 34 | OT | at MIA | |
| 9/17/2016 | Wheaton (11-2,7-1) | 19 | at | Carthage | 14 | |||
| 9/24/2016 | Augustana IL (3-7,1-6) | 24 | at | Carthage | 27 | |||
| 10/1/2016 | Carthage | 38 | at | Carroll WI (1-9) | 14 | at MidW | ||
| 10/15/2016 | Carthage | 37 | at | Elmhurst (5-5,3-4) | 28 | |||
| 10/22/2016 | Illinois Wesleyan (7-2,5-2) | 19 | at | Carthage | 14 | |||
| 10/29/2016 | Carthage | 50 | at | Millikin (4-6,2-5) | 28 | |||
| 11/5/2016 | North Central (11-1,7-1) | 34 | at | Carthage | 21 | |||
| 11/12/2016 | Carthage | 40 | at | North Park (1-9,0-7) | 14 |
| vs Carthage | vs Other Opponents | Carthage compared to OOs | |
| Record: | 3-7 | 51-43 | |
| Points Scored: | 22.50 | 27.02 | 4.52 |
| Points Allowed: | 33.20 | 25.41 | 7.79 |
| Margin: | -10.70 | 1.61 | 12.31 |
| Total Points: | 55.70 | 52.43 | 3.27 |