| 9/6/2014 | Merchant Marine | 23 | at | Apprentice | 19 | | | vs LL |
| Martin Luther | 63 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 24 | | | vs UMWAC |
| Alfred State | 17 | at | Morrisville | 69 | | | @ NJAC |
| Thomas More | 20 | at | Wesley | 35 | | | vs TPAC |
| 9/13/2014 | Rochester | 35 | at | Alfred State | 21 | | | vs LL |
| Bluefield | 46 | at | Apprentice | 24 | | | vs MSC (NAIA) |
| Maranatha Baptist | 0 | at | Lawrence | 59 | | | @ MidW |
| Wesley | 43 | at | Salisbury | 5 | | | @ E8 |
| 9/20/2014 | Apprentice | 24 | at | Catholic | 31 | | | @ ODC |
| Maranatha Baptist | 1 | at | Central IA | 65 | | | @ IIAC |
| Alfred State | 28 | at | Husson | 34 | OT | | @ ECFC |
| Rowan | 7 | at | Wesley | 37 | | | vs NJAC |
| 9/27/2014 | Castleton State | 36 | at | Alfred State | 23 | | | vs ECFC |
| Bridgewater VA | 32 | at | Apprentice | 16 | | | vs ODC |
| Maranatha Baptist | | at | Concordia IL | | | CX Airline Disruption | @ NAC |
| Southern Virginia | 7 | at | Wesley | 47 | | | vs NJAC |
| 10/4/2014 | Apprentice | 30 | at | Alfred State | 44 | | | |
| Trinity Bible | 39 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 0 | | | vs None (Unk?) |
| Louisiana College | 21 | at | Wesley | 56 | | | vs ASWC |
| 10/11/2014 | Wesley | 54 | at | Concordia AL | 0 | | | @ None (Unk?) |
| Maranatha Baptist | 0 | at | Presentation | 49 | | | @ NSAA (NAIA) |
| 10/18/2014 | Wesley | 70 | at | Menlo | 2 | | | @ NAIAInd (NAIA) |
| Maranatha Baptist | | at | Washington U | | | Cancelled | @ UAA |
| 10/25/2014 | St John Fisher | 61 | at | Alfred State | 0 | | | vs E8 |
| Apprentice | 21 | at | Edward Waters | 47 | | | @ Sun (NAIA) |
| Concordia MI | 62 | at | Maranatha Baptist | 0 | | | vs MSFA (NAIA) |
| Wesley | 75 | at | Virginia U-Lynchburg | 12 | | | @ None (Unk?) |
| 11/1/2014 | Alfred State | 34 | at | Apprentice | 39 | | | |
| 11/8/2014 | Webber International | 31 | at | Apprentice | 6 | | | vs Sun (NAIA) |
| Alfred State | 19 | at | Washington U | 47 | | | @ UAA |
| 11/15/2014 | Apprentice | 8 | at | Ave Maria | 35 | | | @ Sun (NAIA) |
| Maranatha Baptist | | at | Kentucky Wesleyan | | | CCD | @ GLV (D2) |
| Wesley | 33 | at | UNC-Charlotte | 38 | | | @ IndFCS (1AA) |
| 11/22/2014 | Hampden-Sydney | 7 | at | Wesley | 52 | | D3 playoff round 1 | vs ODC |
| 11/29/2014 | MIT | 0 | at | Wesley | 59 | | D3 Championship - Second Round | vs NEF |
| 12/6/2014 | Hobart | 13 | at | Wesley | 41 | | D3 Championship - Quarterfinals | vs LL |
| 12/13/2014 | Wesley | 21 | at | Mount Union | 70 | | D3 Championship Semifinal | @ OAC |