| 9/3/2011 | Worcester State Lancers 55 @ Anna Maria 30 | |
| 9/10/2011 | Anna Maria 13 @ Maine Maritime Mariners 42 | |
| 9/24/2011 | Anna Maria 52 @ Castleton State Spartans 56 | † |
| 10/1/2011 | Gallaudet Bison 48 @ Anna Maria 40 | † |
| 10/8/2011 | Mount Ida Mustangs 56 @ Anna Maria 7 | † |
| 10/15/2011 | Anna Maria 13 @ SUNY-Maritime Privateers 34 | † |
| 10/22/2011 | Castleton State Spartans 39 @ Anna Maria 34 | † |
| 10/29/2011 | Anna Maria 24 @ Norwich Cadets 45 | † |
| 11/5/2011 | Becker Hawks 33 @ Anna Maria 35 | † |
| 11/12/2011 | Anna Maria 31 @ Husson Eagles 38 | † |