| 9/3/2005 | Albion | 28 | @ | Butler | 23 | ||||
| 9/10/2005 | Butler | 7 | @ | Tiffin | 30 | ||||
| 9/17/2005 | Butler | 13 | @ | Robert Morris | 49 | ||||
| 9/24/2005 | Butler | 21 | @ | Jacksonville | 55 | Pio | |||
| 10/1/2005 | Morehead St | 58 | @ | Butler | 10 | Pio | |||
| 10/8/2005 | Butler | 7 | @ | San Diego | 49 | Pio | |||
| 10/15/2005 | Valparaiso | 34 | @ | Butler | 21 | Pio | |||
| 10/22/2005 | St Joseph's | 23 | @ | Butler | 7 | ||||
| 10/29/2005 | Butler | 10 | @ | Drake | 56 | Pio | |||
| 11/5/2005 | Dayton | 41 | @ | Butler | 7 | Pio | |||
| 11/12/2005 | Missouri-Rolla | 45 | @ | Butler | 28 |